"A fascinating book that makes an important . . . contribution to the subject of pre-Columbian contacts between America and Europe. . . . Highly recommended."
Choice "Provocative. . . . Turning the concept of 'discovers' on its head, Forbes dispels a lot of common assumptions about who 'discovered' whom in the Americas, in an extensive and fascinating exploration ... Read moreof early maritime histories of the Native Americans."
Bloomsbury Review "Interesting and thought provoking. . . . [Forbes] raises many significant questions."
American Anthropologist "Highly refreshing. . . .Very convincing."
Elixir “[Forbes’] extensive use of manuscript or published sources, interviews, and correspondence with specialists in a wide variety of fields is impressive.”
Terrae Incognitae "Readers will find much to ponder in this volume, and the extensive bibliography is a valuable guide to further study."
Journal of Interdisciplinary History "Forbes makes an unusual and fascinating contribution to the story of the New and Old Worlds and the links between them, questioning in a welcome way the truth and ideological sway of orthodox history. He leads his reader along paths rarely, if ever, trodden, ultimately in search of a fairer account of native America and its role in the world. This is a quest Forbes's own ancestry and
not least
keen sense of language well equip him to undertake. He eminently succeeds."
Gordon Brotherston, author of Image of the New World: The American Continent Portrayed in Native Texts "A decisive, independent, and long overdue contribution that pulls the plug from the inflated icon the Christian West has made of the slaver Christopher Columbus in his mistaken attempt to reach India."
Hartmut Lutz, professor of American studies, Greifswald University, Germany Show Less