In producing this volume Anemone and Scotto have faced not just a challenge of translation, but also one of organization and interpretation. They have extracted material from the notebooks and arranged it in chronological order. They have added a potted biography, notes on their approach to the selection and treatment of the notebook entries, a chronology of events from Kharms's ... Read morelife and times, a glossary of people, places and concepts, and a copious commentary to contextualize the entries. Yet, for all this imposed order, they have striven to represent the 'wild heterogeneity' (p. 45) of the original notebooks. The result is a fascinating, if disjointed, read. . . . Whether they represent a new genre or a collision of genres, the notebooks certainly offer another point of departure for elaborating Kharms's artistic legacy. . . . Remaining true to [Iakov] Druskin's view that life and art are close to indistinguishable in an author like Kharms, Anemone and Scotto have adopted a policy of maximum disclosure. This excellent compilation of Kharms's notebooks can be seen, therefore, as both a biographical portrait and a literary-critical assessment.
Neil Carrick The Slavonic and East European Review, Vol. 92, No. 3 (July 2014) As the [editors] themselves clearly indicated in the section about their translation, their intention to write a creative biography in documents has been thoroughly accomplished. It is obvious that the [editors] are intimately familiar with and have made extensive use of the original handwritten sources and original documents. The translations are of a very high quality showing that the [editors] have attempted to bring out the full meaning of Kharms' writings. For anyone interested in Daniil Kharms, his life and his times this book constitutes an invaluable source.
Ayse Dietrich (Middle East Technical University) International Journal of Russian Studies, Issue No. 3 (2014/2) The volume is unquestionably the most comprehensive biographical resource on Kharms available in English. . . . Avid Kharms readers will certainly enjoy the wealth of materials that this collection brings together and may be surprised by some aspects of his personality revealed here (for instance, his enthusiasm for chess problems). The book is also to be recommended to anyone with an interest in the Russian avant-grade or everyday life in 1920s and 1930s Leningrad. . . . The volume provides an excellent display of the style of an author whose dictum on writing applies equally well to his professional activities and his personal papers: 'Always write with an interest and look on writing as a holiday' (483).
Geoff Cebula Slavic and East European Journal, 58.2 (Summer 2014) Those familiar with Kharms (1905-1942) won't need encouragement to pick up this collection of writing, much of it translated for the first time; this writer, a Soviet avant-garde legend, could make a dog laugh.
Book News, Inc. Gives the best sense of any book in English of Kharms both within his context and as a deeply fascinating individual whose work can't be explained away by the circumstances of its creation. . . . A huge addition to the Kharms canon in English. . . . Dozens of entries translated here for the first time that are just as great, as weird and delightful and mysterious, as his better-known works.
Chris Cumming BOMBlog [Kharms's notebooks] are generously sampled and gracefully translated by Anemone (The New School) and Scotto (Mount Holyoke College). . . . Not only have they succeeded in producing a vivid, often poignant portrait of Kharms, they offer a host of new texts in English
many as funny, violent, and profoundly existential as any seen before. . . . Highly recommended.
M. Kasper (professor emeritus, Amherst College) Anemone and Scotto do an outstanding job in conveying the texture of Kharms's writings. . . . The notebooks, diaries, and letters presented in 'I Am a Phenomenon' show the breadth of Kharms's interests, in literature, music, art, philosophy, psychology, mathematics, religion. . . . Certain sections of the book can be seen as a creative workshop for Kharms's literary works. . . a glimpse of contexts into which readers can place their knowledge of his literary works. More than that, the book documents Kharms's hopes, doubts, frustrations, and physical and psychic pains about work and life. . . . Anemone and Scotto have done an excellent job. They state, 'We believe that we have remained true to the spirit of the notebooks' (p. 43). Absolutely!
Ellen Chances The Russian Review, January 2014 Show Less