'Extraordinarily timely. Deeply researched and based on hundreds of interviews, fair-minded and empathetic, [Minder's] account of the Catalan rebellion invites the reader into a multi-voiced conversation, with a genial author there to prompt when one loses track.'
Financial Times 'The offer of independence, as Raphael Minder says in his invaluable new work, The Struggle for Catalonia, promised change ... Read moreand prosperity in a new Catalan state, instead of stagnation in a rotten Spain .'
Owen Jones '[A] balanced and sympathetic account'
The Nation 'Timely and useful'
The Irish Times 'One of the virtues of Minder's elegantly written book is that his roughly two hundred interviews with politicians, journalists, and scholars give it an evenhanded approach to the situation in Catalonia ... Minder's book is valuable not only for what it explains but for what it describes ... the book is an ode to Barcelona, Catalonia's glittering capital and one of Europe's most cosmopolitan cities.'
The New York Review of Books 'What the reader really values is the depth and breadth of this book . . an excellent analysis of Catalonia, from its cuisine to its language to its tempestuous politics.' 'His recently-published book is a comprehensive, highly readable survey of what it is troubling Catalonia at present ... There are undoubtedly many readers in the Anglophone world who wish to read beyond the daily news reports concerning Catalonia, and this book, written from a neutral, indeed tactful point of enquiry, answers all the questions.'
RTE 'Refreshingly even-handed in the midst of all the fire and fury in the Spanish media, Minder's book, based on thorough historical research, points to an unavoidable train crash between Catalonia and the rest of Spain. The book's conclusion is hard to refute. Any attempt to reunite the peoples of Spain will continue to fail so long as there is no effort on the part of the political establishment in Madrid to attempt what Minder has ably endeavoured to do in his book: understand the feelings expressed by hundreds of thousands on the streets of Barcelona .'
Literary Review 'Employing his talents as a journalist who has covered Spain for the New York Times since 2010, Minder bases his highly readable exploration of Catalonia on countless interviews with political, social, and business leaders as well as scholars, activists, and everyday people . . . he insightfully describes how secessionist sentiment and related tensions are interwoven with an array of topics in Catalan life. . . Minder's insights about this region will intrigue.' 'Raphael Minder's timely book . . . has provoked significant interest throughout the English speaking world. As New York Times correspondent in Spain and Portugal, Minder draws on interviews with a very impressive list of protagonists . . . for this reason alone, as well as for its comprehensiveness, Minder's book is worthy of reading for those looking to develop an understanding of the complex Catalan, and overall Spanish, question.' 'A brilliant study of Spain's Catalan problem by a careful and conscientious journalist who has spoken to all the key players and missed absolutely nothing. Minder is an engaging writer, who combines sharp firsthand reporting with analysis that manages to be sceptical, thoughtful, insightful and non-partisan in equal measure. The result is an indispensable English-language guide to the political complexities of Catalonia's struggle for independence, which also takes readers deep into Catalan history and culture. A terrific achievement.'
Matthew Carr, author of Blood and Faith: The Purging of Muslim Spain, 1492-1614 and The Devils of Cardona 'The current independence movement in Catalonia has wide implications not only for Spain but for Europe. In this timely and well-informed book the New York Times correspondent in Spain uses his numerous interviews with partisans and opponents of secession to give readers a balanced account of the issues at stake.'
John Elliott, Regius Professor Emeritus of Modern History, University of Oxford 'Few people in the Anglo-Saxon world understand why relations between Catalonia and the Spanish capital are so tense. On the basis of 200 interviews with politicians, journalists, historians and restaurateurs, Raphael Minder's even-handed and compellingly readable work explains the past and the possible future of a dangerous situation.'
Paul Preston, Professor of Contemporary Spanish History, London School of Economics and Political Science, and author of The Last Days of the Spanish Republic 'A very serious and well-documented book that helps shed light on as complicated a topic as the relationship between Catalonia and the rest of Spain. An outsider's analysis, lucid and objective, that also displays a clear desire to promote fraternity.'
Josep Pique, former Spanish Foreign Minister 'Raphael Minder's scrupulously impartial and lucid book is based on wide-ranging interviews and historical study. He navigates the complexities of this thorny issue very successfully.'
Jose Alvarez Junco, Professor of History, Universidad Complutense de Madrid; author of Spanish Identity in the Age of Nations Show Less