Well researched and judiciously selective, not to mention fastidiously politically correct — nearly every chapter includes a sub-section on women — Steven Fielding’s study makes a concise and thought-provoking shadow history of modern British politics.
Houman Barekat
The Spectator
[A] brilliant analysis of a simple, obvious and usually overlooked idea: that what people think about politics is ... Read moreformed as much by popular fictions as by media reporting of politics itself.
John Rentoul
The Independent
Britain has an honourable tradition of puncturing the pomposity of the powerful. But Professor Steven Fielding contends that rather than merely reflect the problems with our politics, such satires help to create them. Unable to distinguish between fact and fiction, viewers are left with a view of MPs as irremediably crooked. It is an argument that liberals will instinctively revolt against, but by the end of Fielding’s analysis, at least some will be left with the uneasy feeling that he may well be right.
New Statesman
Steven Fielding has grasped something that has been staring British politics in the face for years without anyone else seeming to notice. Fiction and screen representations don't simply reflect the crisis of politics. As Fielding shows, they are an active part of that crisis too
Martin Kettle, The Guardian
In a witty, empirically dense and provocative book, Fielding argues that culture has always informed, for good and ill, popular perceptions of politics. It entwines fiction, films, plays and politics – where else can you find obscure turn-of-the-century cinema gems and forgotten ITV dramas alongside Anthony Trollope and Malcolm Tucker? Could this be a book that nudges political history out of its methodological impasse?
Lawrence Black
Times Higher Education
Fielding is a prodigious reader and his book will lead aficionados towards many long-forgotten novels.
Times Higher Education Supplement
[A State of Play] is a scholarly and meticulously research study of how novels, plays, films and television have influenced the way we view our politicians. Fielding has written a cosy, engrossing treatise, informing and educating the reader even as you enjoy the comfortable familiarity of all the examples and case studies he cites
Sarla Langdon
The Bay, Issue 59
[A] richly detailed and rewarding book.
Jeffrey Richards
History Today
Steven Fielding's book provides an insightful overview of British political fiction ... A useful and entertaining book; one with a good deal of useful analysis on how the British have interpreted politics over time.
Political Studies Review
Show Less